Browsed by
Tag: income

Does everyone need to work?

Does everyone need to work?

“This is why so much contemporary discussion of work and meaning is misguided. It’s very clear that humans don’t need work or anything like it to live meaningful lives. Nor do we need the things that people who talk about “meaning” mean — individual self-actualization, personal growth, serving a greater purpose. We can get by just fine without any of them, as historically most of us have. What we absolutely can’t live without is a social framework for understanding ourselves in relation to the rest of our society and gaining the respect of our peers. The most important thing work gives us — after money, of course — is an alternative way to meet those needs. Not all jobs are pleasant or rewarding, but all of us benefit from living in a system where we can earn respect and dignity as adults from what we do, not who we know, or who we are.” – After work, we’ll have each other by Clara Collier

I was at my weekly friend get-together evening with two girlfriends recently when the topic of kids and careers came up. One friend was vehemently on the side of “get a good education, get a job, be able to support yourself.” while another friend was of the opinion that “not everyone needs to work.” Of course, our knee jerk reaction is very much like the first friend’s point of view and I think that is because it is the common viewpoint in most western societies. But historically, not everyone worked – at least not all of the time – in the ways we do now. Also, when you think about it our current set-up is relatively new (and “jobs” being not what we would call most labour in the past). Even today we have tons of people who don’t have jobs in the traditional sense but we are all working at one thing or another. Is a novelist a novelist even if they aren’t published yet? If they do get published, is the term novelist retroactively applied to them as their occupation? If they never get published did they never have an occupation at all? At the core of it is the question of labour being tied to money but being a stay-at-home-mom was the most work I have EVER done in my life (and why I went back to work – the lunch hour!) so how do we wrestle with the future when labour may not be tied to income at all?

I think AI is really getting people to ponder that question.